13 Responses to “Living Overseas and Coming Back”

Comments

Read below or add a comment...

  1. Thank U very, very much.

    U have helped me with my homework =D

  2. Thanks for this site, my mother language is Spanish and as you know, English is very important for us.

  3. Uncle Irv

    Hey Mauricio,
    I am glad we could help you.
    Are you in Spain?
    cheers Mark

  4. Brendon Stewart

    this site is a great resource, it’d be even better if you did take every opportunity to take a swipe at the united states. considering that the majority of ESL speakers lack access to independent media, it doesnt help that you paint a completey one sided picture of the united states. stick to the langauge learning.

  5. Dear Brendan

    Thanks for your comment. Why can’t I take a swipe at the United States? Why can’t I criticize or praise anything according to how I honestly feel about it even when I am in the classroom?

    Who lacks access to independent media? Considering the relationship between media and big business, what is independent media?

    I personally am a big fan of American literature and the American ideals of democracy and political freedom, freedom from fear, the Bill of Rights etc etc. I have had wonderful experiences traveling in the States and would love to go back and meet more of the wonderful friendly and diverse people.

    I am however critical of the current American government and its foreign policy. That would naturally come out in a conversation if it was real, right? Won’t that improve the quality of the language learning? Maybe not for everybody?

    Maybe you and I have a really different take on teaching and education or maybe not? Do you think it is wrong to talk about politics and religion, for example? I love openness but I hate to cause pain or suffering in any way.

    No offence intended.
    Cheers Mark

    ps If you think there are one-sided comments or controversial viewpoints in the material, why not mention this to your students and see if you can turn it into a class discussion.

    pps Just as the waters of the Mississipi that flow from the border of Canada down to the Gulf of Mexico do not separate but unite and nurture the east and west coasts of the United States of America, so too may we be united and nurtured by the spirit of friendship and knowledge.

  6. Brendon Stewart

    Mark,

    I appreciate your reply. And again, I greatly appreciate English Conversations, it is an excellent resource for English language learners.

    I am an American volunteer in a country that receives all of its information and images of the outside world from the central government. I actually love to talk about religion and politics, and wish the country in which I teach felt the same.

    While I am not a fan of the current American government , I do not believe it is constructive to engage in stereotyping (negative or positive). People fortunate enough to be raised in societies with liberal education systems will immediately recognize your comments as one-sided and biased, but for those raised in societies where critical thinking is discouraged, like the one in which I live, some of your dialogues may serve to reinforce close-mindedness.

    If I were learning Russian, I would not expect every language dialogue to be contain statements about the Stalinist purges, KGB repression, or xenophobic Russian nationalism. If I were learning Japanese, I would not expect information about the Imperial Army’s massacres in China and the Japanese public’s inability to honestly confront such atrocities in their national memory. These are messages governments (including my own) spread to their people to inspire fear-based nationalism.

    As more open-minded individuals, I believe we should do a better job of promoting understanding through education. Nothing that you say about America is untrue, but it is presented in a way that does not help people objectively understand the country. Instead, it is presented in a way that shuns openess and invites ignorance.

    Just my personal thoughts. No offense taken and I will continue to use the site.

    Cheers,
    Brendon

  7. Hey Brendon…

    Thanks so much for taking the time to give us feedback. We appreciate that.

    I see our primary purpose here as to provide language learning materials to anyone who would find them useful. We have no political purpose. One of our categories is “real conversations” which intends to present the language as it is actually spoken, rather than as it often is in recordings: contrived dialogs.

    As you know, content and meaning cannot be separated from the language, so any natural conversation is going to contain evidence of prejudices and ignorance, whether subtle or gross. We cannot totally remove those either, as some are contained within the language itself! So to “stick to the language learning” just isn’t feasible when it comes to offering “real” conversations to learners.

    I would hope, however, that as the body of conversations here grows, all different perspectives are presented, so that there is no dominance of any particular viewpoint. In this sense, your comments are helpful in reminding us of that. Perhaps the type of people that Mark has encountered recently have been of a particular “genre of folk,” for lack of a better description.

    However, I am truly confounded when you write that what is said about America (meaning the U.S.) is “presented in a way that shuns openness and invites ignorance.” I don’t see that as a major – or even minor – theme anywhere throughout the content posted in the site, so I am having difficulty understanding that particular comment. Mark and I fully support and embody openness in our work and in our lives. Through this site we are tying to bring people and ideas together by sharing voices – which contain a wealth of meaning and a treasure of culture.

    Nevertheless, I think it is dialogue like the one we are engaging in now that is a fruit of the raw, organic process: the way we speak. I think that one of the things that makes some of the conversations we post unique, is that they stimulate people to examine a particular reality in ways that they never have before. And anytime you do that, you are not inviting ignorance, but rather stimulating the growth of awareness and understanding.

    Again, thank you for your comments.

    Aaron

  8. Felicia

    I’m glad find this site in google search..It’s really help me to do my homework. Also can learn by audio not only in grammar..Thank u very much…We always need English to do assigment in college..

  9. Sieu nhan gao

    Thank you very much!

  10. Ismael from guadalajara mex

    I`m from Guadalajara and I`m new in your web site I`ve tried to learn english for a long time without good results, but now with your web site im improving my english i can feel it, with real english conversation.
    Thank you very much! Mark
    plase show us more.

Leave A Comment...